Thoughts contingent on Emma Bull's Territory
* It was something of a disconcerting experience to read a book set in the area where I grew up. Just like seeing that dreadful car/ghost movie they shot in the Tucson valley, and identifying the various roads the editors spliced together in order to make it fit. The Tombstone I know is worlds away from the one described in the book, and although I know logically that in the late 1800's, the silver hadn't run out, so there actually WAS money there, and it actually WAS considered a large city -- larger than Tucson, which owed its origin to a Spanish Mission, and its railroad pinning down the bottom end of the Oregon Trail, rather than mineral wealth, -- it's still disconcerting to read about opera houses and theatre engagements in what my brain keeps illustrating as a mostly-forgotten all-but-ghost town, where the only industry or wealth comes from reenactments and tours for the tourists.
* That said, I really enjoyed this book. Really enjoyed it a lot. Growing up in the Tucson valley, as I did, I'd grown a leather ear toward the endlessly-repeated story of the shootout at the O.K. Corrall, so it was a bit frustrating hearing the names of people whom I knew had been involved, but whose allegiances in the fight I couldn't recall, specifically. It might have deepened my enjoyment of this story, like a hint of salt in a sweet coffee, but not having a basis of comparison, I can't say for certain. I definitely felt that the author had a solid handle on the people she was illustrating, and whatever history or hollywood might think of them, she made them fit beautifully into the weft of the tale she meant to tell with them.
* It was pure vanity that made me self-identify with Kate Holiday. I'm a big enough cat to admit that. And likely pure fancy that made me imagine Doc's lines in Dominus' voice. Or perhaps it was that they seemed so devotedly in love, and indulgent of each other's weaknesses, while shoring up whatever actual vulnerabilities they could reach that made me think that doomed relationship smacked of my own. Only, of course, Dominus is not dying of consumption, thanks everso and knock wood.
* The finish of the book does not demand a sequel, but there's enough room left for one that I shouldn't be surprised to see Milicent Benjamin and Jesse Fox appear to drive along another book. I'd be surprised to see it set in Tombstone though, since I feel the author made a considerable effort to foreshadow the history everyone knows, while steering clear of the common story. Setting a follow up there without banging on about the O.K. and its casualties would be really difficult, I think, and to tell the truth, there's not a lot more that went on there, aside from Wyatt Earp taking over the town.
* The red herring was nicely dealt in this story. Very smooth, and very well hidden in plain sight until the hand was called. And the scene with the Poker game in the Oriental Hotel was pure brilliance. It had me laughing aloud, which was inconvenient, since I was on the treadmill, and working out at the time, and didn't have all that much breath to spare for it.
* I liked the book. It won't change anybody's world, but it's a good read, and I can think of half a dozen people I might gift it to by way of a Brighid present. So take that for what you consider it worth, I suppose.
<td bgcolor="#CEB28B" align="center">Finished</td>
<td bgcolor="#CEB28B" align="center">Book Title</td>
<td bgcolor="#CEB28B" align="center">Author</td>
<td bgcolor="#CEB28B" align="center">Genre</td>
<td bgcolor="#CEB28B" align="center">Pages</td>
</tr>
* That said, I really enjoyed this book. Really enjoyed it a lot. Growing up in the Tucson valley, as I did, I'd grown a leather ear toward the endlessly-repeated story of the shootout at the O.K. Corrall, so it was a bit frustrating hearing the names of people whom I knew had been involved, but whose allegiances in the fight I couldn't recall, specifically. It might have deepened my enjoyment of this story, like a hint of salt in a sweet coffee, but not having a basis of comparison, I can't say for certain. I definitely felt that the author had a solid handle on the people she was illustrating, and whatever history or hollywood might think of them, she made them fit beautifully into the weft of the tale she meant to tell with them.
* It was pure vanity that made me self-identify with Kate Holiday. I'm a big enough cat to admit that. And likely pure fancy that made me imagine Doc's lines in Dominus' voice. Or perhaps it was that they seemed so devotedly in love, and indulgent of each other's weaknesses, while shoring up whatever actual vulnerabilities they could reach that made me think that doomed relationship smacked of my own. Only, of course, Dominus is not dying of consumption, thanks everso and knock wood.
* The finish of the book does not demand a sequel, but there's enough room left for one that I shouldn't be surprised to see Milicent Benjamin and Jesse Fox appear to drive along another book. I'd be surprised to see it set in Tombstone though, since I feel the author made a considerable effort to foreshadow the history everyone knows, while steering clear of the common story. Setting a follow up there without banging on about the O.K. and its casualties would be really difficult, I think, and to tell the truth, there's not a lot more that went on there, aside from Wyatt Earp taking over the town.
* The red herring was nicely dealt in this story. Very smooth, and very well hidden in plain sight until the hand was called. And the scene with the Poker game in the Oriental Hotel was pure brilliance. It had me laughing aloud, which was inconvenient, since I was on the treadmill, and working out at the time, and didn't have all that much breath to spare for it.
* I liked the book. It won't change anybody's world, but it's a good read, and I can think of half a dozen people I might gift it to by way of a Brighid present. So take that for what you consider it worth, I suppose.
| Dec 30 | Butcher Bird | Richard Kadrey | Urban Fantasy | 257 |
| Jan 09 | Territory | Emma Bull | Historical Fantasy | Audio |